When disaster strikes, the investigation is only part of the story. What happens to the families left behind? Who answers their questions, helps them navigate the unimaginable, and makes sure they aren’t forgotten in the aftermath?
On this episode of OnTopic with Empathia, Jennifer Stansberry Miller sits down with Sharon Bryson, former NTSB Managing Director and disaster assistance leader, and Kathryn Turman, who established and led the FBI’s Victim Services Division, to explore how families and survivors helped reshape disaster response in America.
Drawing on their experiences with tragedies including Pan Am Flight 103, the Oklahoma City bombing, and September 11, they share how listening to families, coordinating agencies, and building relationships transformed the way organizations support victims and survivors.
Download the related white paper.
Whether it’s delivering a high-value employee assistance program, student support, or responding to a crisis in your organization or community, OnTopic with Empathia brings competence, compassion, and commitment to those who need it most. Find out more at https://www.empathia.com.
Click here for the full episode transcription
00;00;08;27 – 00;02;24;23
Jenn Stansberry Miller
Welcome to OnTopic with Empathia. I’m Jen Stansberry Miller, Director of Crisis Solutions at Empathia. After we lost my brother Brad Stansberry in the crash of American Eagle Flight 4184, my parents began asking questions, demanding answers and pushing for change. I later joined families and survivors affected by more than ten aviation disasters, and a collective effort to advocate for and pass the Aviation Disaster Family Assistance Act of 1996. 30 years later, its influence reaches beyond aviation. Over two episodes, we’ll speak with individuals who helped turn family and survivor needs into lasting programs. Sharon Bryson helped develop and lead the NTSB Transportation Disaster Assistance Program, strengthening support for survivors and bereaved families. She also helped other countries build their own transportation disaster assistance programs. She later served as NTSB managing director and now directs the Delaware Office of Highway Safety. Her commitment to families was recognized in 2011 when she was named a Service to America Medals finalist. Kathryn Turman established and led the FBI’s Victim Service Division. She helped make the Pan Am 103 trial accessible to families, and created the FBI’s Victim Services Response Team for Terrorism and mass casualty events. For her work with the Pan Am 103 families, she received the Justice Department’s highest honor, the Edmund J. Randolph Award. Today, we’ll explore how families shaped their work, what it took to establish practices, and how those lessons informed responses to other disasters. Sharon and Katherine, welcome- I’m grateful to have you both here. Before we begin, would each of you like to share a little bit about your background, how you came to this work? Sharon?
00;02;24;25 – 00;03;46;20
Sharon Bryson
So I, I was the family Support Center director at Dover Air Force Base when the NTSB got the legislation, the Aviation Disaster Assistance Act was passed, and NTSB needed to build the program. It you know, irony, I guess maybe I had just gotten done, assisting with the, Ron Brown crash, the Dubrovnik Croatia crash that killed Secretary- Commerce Secretary Brown and the Khobar Tower bombing and a few of the other sort of large scale events that had taken place. I was here in Delaware doing some training on mass fatality management when I met a member of the NTSB who was out in the field trying to find people. Who they thought maybe could work in the program. And so I really didn’t know a lot about the history on the civilian side of things up until that point. But then, over, I don’t know, 8 or 9 months of conversation. I’ll just say between myself and the and the agency, I made the decision to to join the team and help them build the program.
00;03;46;22 – 00;03;49;06
Jenn Stansberry Miller
In what year did you come again?
00;03;49;09 – 00;03;51;04
Sharon Bryson
November of 1997.
00;03;51;06 – 00;03;55;09
Jenn Stansberry Miller
That’s right. Okay. Katherine, how’d you start out?
00;03;55;11 – 00;05;17;18
Kathryn Turman
I sort of… fell into it a little bit, but I, I started out, I graduated from college, spent ten years in Dallas trying to figure out what I wanted to do and what I didn’t want to do, and eventually ended up moving to D.C. and worked on the Hill for a U.S. senator who, ironically, died in a plane crash three years after I started working for him. But during that time, Pan Am 103 happened and we had some things involvement with that. And then after John was killed, I went to the Justice Department, where I was director of the Missing and Exploited Children’s Program for a number of years. Then Eric Holder, who was the U.S. attorney for the District of Columbia, recruited me to come over to his office and and run their victim assistance and witness security programs. So I did that for a while, and then I got recruited, drafted to go to the office for Victims of crime, where I was for three and a half years, I think, where I met Sharon. And then shortly after nine over 11, I was recruited again to go over to the FBI, drafted. There’s there’s a line and I don’t know if you’ve ever seen… well, MASH, but there’s a line where Hot Lips Houlihan gets mad at Hawkeye Pierce and demands to know how someone like him ever got into the army, and he just looked at her and said, I was drafted. And that’s kind of the way I feel about a good part of my career.
00;05;17;21 – 00;05;20;04
Jenn Stansberry Miller
Wonderful! Wonderful.
00;05;20;11 – 00;05;21;22
Sharon Bryson
That’s great.
00;05;21;24 – 00;06;08;02
Jenn Stansberry Miller
All right, so let’s dive in, shall we? Let’s start with the families in survivors who helped shape your work and the relationship you two collectively built along the way. So first topic, let’s go ahead and start with sharing your work. Help shape the NTSB Family Assistance program. Kathryn. Yours included supporting the Pan Am 103 families, especially through the criminal trial. So respectively, how did you both incorporate aviation family experiences and survivors into your career, and how did it impact and influence really the inception of your respective programs?
00;06;08;05 – 00;09;11;08
Sharon Bryson
So I think the one piece that I’ll see is sort of missing in the time frame, if I remember correctly. Kathryn, please correct me. You were more involved in this than I was, but, the Oklahoma City bombing occurred. Yeah. And following the I had I had come into the NTSB in that basic time frame when all of that was going on and there was a an interest in movement, I’ll call it, I don’t know what it was, but, to move in a particular direction that I wasn’t particularly comfortable with. I didn’t know Kathryn at the time. She was at OVC over at justice, and, I was invited into a meeting where I was pretty vocal about my feelings with regard to that. And, you know, Kathryn, I had no idea who Kathryn was. She got up and walked out of the meeting at one point to go attend to something else. And at the end of the meeting, a lady came and said, the director would like to speak to you before you leave. And I thought, boy, I haven’t been in DC for more than, I don’t know, a couple of months and I’m already being told to leave. And so they took me around a corner into this big office that had windows on all sides of it, as I recall. And there’s this lady sitting at the desk behind the desk, and it ends up being Kathryn who had been in the meeting, but I didn’t know she was the director, and I thought, I am in real trouble now. And she said, sit down. I like the way you think. You and I are going to get along just fine. And so some of that started around things that were happening with the Oklahoma City. And I’ll just say, I didn’t feel like the right attention was being placed on certain parts of the response. In particular, some of the needs that families had, I didn’t think was being prioritized enough. And so that’s really where we got to know each other and sort of started to, I think, move, move the needle more in the direction of here’s what families are telling us would be helpful. And if they don’t know, I don’t know, who knows. So we should pay attention to what the families have to say. Here are the recommendations from the task force. You know, this is really where we need to have our time and energy focused and started to kind of move things a little bit in a different direction. At least that was my recollection of that particular time period. But I thought I was just going to get run out of town for running my mouth. When I, got to D.C. and was starting to figure out how to build the program. So, yeah.
00;09;11;10 – 00;10;19;19
Kathryn Turman
I remember that. I mean, you were the first person who spoke sort of sense and spoke honestly about that. I mean, I think we shared some of the same concerns, but Oklahoma City was kind of a major change. It was other. I mean, it was really the first major, huge, mass casualty on U.S. soil. So I think people started looking at things a little bit differently, and it seemed like at the right time you were trying to work out NTSB. I was dealing with OVC. We had Mag over at DoD, Beth Nelson at SAMHSa, right. Jane Morgan, everybody was sort of trying to deal with the same sort of issues, which was how do we develop an effective response to mass fatalities, mass casualties, particularly meeting the real needs of families and survivors, instead of just putting into place what we think they need, but actually really learning from them and figuring out what’s important at what time. So I think it was just sort of everything kind of gelled around this. There were just a number of us trying to figure out what the heck we were doing.
00;10;19;21 – 00;10;32;08
Jenn Stansberry Miller
And that leads us to the next question is, what did the families need that existing systems, we’re not created or were insufficient to provide at that time?
00;10;32;10 – 00;12;04;06
Sharon Bryson
I feel like the things that they needed were there. I think that there were good people trying to do the right thing, but there was no coordination. So all of that attempt to do the right thing. And there were some people that weren’t qualified, and who needed to not be there. I’ll also say that I’m not, you know, I live in La La land occasionally, but not that far into lala land. Yeah. There were people who weren’t appropriate to be interacting, certainly directly with family members. But I, I feel like there was there was there was plenty of services and support. It just there was no coordination. There was no single point of contact. There was no place that families could go where they knew they could get the truth. And, and they could get assistance, whatever that might be and whatever form that might be. And it was really a matter of trying to figure out how to make all that, work together and to support multiple agencies. We’re trying to do the same thing for the same people as opposed to using our resources wisely. Some of those kind of things were going on. So, coordinating and, building that framework that, the agencies and the people within the agencies could work, could work with them.
00;12;04;09 – 00;15;08;04
Kathryn Turman
Yeah. I came, you know, with my major experience with mass casualty stuff was with Pan Am 103 a little bit early on. But as I got to know the families, particularly when we got to the trial, their experience, which was basically very complex. Here you have an aircraft full of 259 souls who the plane gets blown up at 31,000ft. Families, victims and belongings, you know, slip out of the plane into the into the onto the ground, onto the town of Lockerbie, where you had people who had victims remains on their roofs and on their farm farms and churchyards and everything else. People in Lockerbie loving were killed. Half the town was burned. And then you had there was nothing. I mean, there was nothing for these people. Pan Am unfortunately, did not do a great job. There wasn’t a lot in place for them. The victims were from 21 different countries, 190 Americans. Nobody was in charge of family assistance. And the best the families got were the ones who actually went over to Scotland in the early days, who were treated very well by the smallest police force in the United Kingdom, and the townspeople of Lockerbie and some others who really just out of the goodness of their heart, their generosity and kindness, took care of these people to the best they could. There was a massive investigation. The FBI was involved. FBI actually had responsibilities at the time for keeping families victims informed. Didn’t really they weren’t really aware of that. So for years, the only help the families got was from themselves, basically, and a few advocates along the way. So my first experience with the mass casualty really was their experience, which was not great. And what I think was missing most was just and for a lot of these families, they thought for years that there had to be just one phone number, one agency in the federal government that they could call and they could get answers, they could get help, and they didn’t know where it was and it didn’t exist. So like I said, they had to pretty much pull themselves together and take care of each other. Formed family groups, filed a civil suit against Pan Am. So, their experience really made a huge impact on me because you can have all the resources, as Sharon said. But if it’s not coordinated and planned well and executed well, then it’s a problem. And people need that immediate information, immediate support. And it’s going to evolve over time. But if it doesn’t happen right from the beginning, if the death notifications aren’t handled well, all of those things, it just it leaves scars, additional scars for those families. And it destroys or hampers building trust between the agencies that are responsible for an investigation and response and those families and survivors.
00;15;08;07 – 00;15;47;14
Jenn Stansberry Miller
So I’m reflecting on that a moment because I just the the impact of the Pan Am 103 families. I mean, they definitely influenced your side of the lane, but also ours. I mean, their their family associations, their leadership, their advocacy definitely shaped us coming around to advocate for the act. And of course, they were a part of it. But being able to draw upon their experience in Lockerbie, their experience here with the government was just it really is priceless. That lived experience is powerful.
00;15;47;20 – 00;17;38;29
Kathryn Turman
When the trial came up, which was 11.5 years after the bombing, and the U.S. government had a lot of making up to do with these families. And fortunately, we had an attorney general who was front and center all about taking care of the families, you know, willing to go to the mat. Got money from Congress, you know, basically gave us a blank check. But what we did was I we started meeting with the families and just asking them, what do you want? What do you expect? What is your experience been? We’ve got this weird trial as a UN broker trial in a third country where none of the victims actually live or the families, and it’s going to be under Scottish law. But with a panel of judge, it’s not a jury. And how on earth are all these people from around the world going to be able to access the trial? So, like I said, the first thing we did was sit down with people, with families and listen to them. We sent out a survey, along with the Scottish Crown Office asking people what they wanted, and some of them were familiar with the Oklahoma City bombing trials, where there had been a remote broadcast from Denver back to Oklahoma. So they wanted that. And frankly, I my first response was just hand me one and call me Tinker Bell, because I don’t know how the heck we’re going to get the Scottish Court anybody. How would you even do it, you know, mechanically? So, but we put together a plan, and I talked to the folks who did the Oklahoma City bombing trial, and they gave us some good ideas. And this we were able to get the support of the Scottish Court to do a lot of different things. But, you know, we had families that would never be able to travel to the trial. So we had a trial website that had the transcripts posted every day on the on the website, and we paid for travel from for families from anywhere in the world to come to the trial or to one of the remote viewing sites and to briefings. And we covered mental health costs for people who needed to go into therapy. So-
00;17;39;00 – 00;17;40;02
Jenn Stansberry Miller
Tremendous!
00;17;40;04 – 00;17;46;21
Kathryn Turman
-but that was all because we listened to them and figured out what they needed and wanted and made it work!
00;17;46;23 – 00;18;05;18
Jenn Stansberry Miller
In reflecting upon your respective careers. What do you. Can you pinpoint one thing that you’re like, yes, we got right from a operational standpoint that remains essential today?
00;18;05;21 – 00;20;59;06
Kathryn Turman
When I went to the FBI and we had just not only 911 that we were dealing with, but the casualties, civilian terrorist casualties from the Iraq and Afghanistan conflicts, other terrorist attacks occurring in Bali and Africa and all these different places, not to mention all the usual violent crime that the FBI dealt with across the country. But it became very clear after nine over 11 and then some of the, first mass shootings, like Virginia Tech and the Red Lake Reservation, that we needed a different way to respond to those, types of situations, and it needed to be more immediate. So Sharon will remember this. We created, a victim services response team that originally began with 25 FBI victim specialists and people from our office at headquarters and eventually expanded to about 90 employees who were agents, analysts, ERP, evidence recovery folks, as well as all the FBI victims, specialists that have been trained so that we could, respond very quickly to any mass casualty and make sure that some of the things got done from the beginning. And a lot of times we were in a position of support for local communities because it wasn’t necessarily a federal crime. So we would go in very carefully and offer whatever support we could and be a force multiplier. But we learned very quickly about from Sharon and then from the Pan Am experience about the importance of personal effects and effectively managing those and recognizing the importance that they have to families, but also just getting immediate support, helping with things like repatriation of remains. Other things that most people, most families would never be able to think about. So, we took all those sort of lessons and we cobbled together stuff we learned from NTSB, from DoD other places, and just tried to put them all together into sort of a response, plan that worked pretty well. But I think the most important thing we we actually were able to do. Eventually was to make sure that the response to survivors and families was incorporated into the FBI’s operational and crisis response plans from the headquarters, Siak, the operations center on down to the field command post when there was an incident. So it took a lot of years, but getting that in there so that at least there was somebody at a high level who had a voice and who was reminding people about the needs of the survivors and families. And, and that I saw two because I know with sharing with the NTSB, they were able to really bring their investigators along, over a period of years to really appreciating the same thing.
00;20;59;08 – 00;21;19;19
Sharon Bryson
Yeah. It, it I think for me, it was really seeing the, the culture change. Right. The and understanding that it early on it was there’s an investigation, there’s an incident, there’s an investigation and then there’s that victim assistance piece we’ll get and we’ll kind of like we’ll get to that for the.
00;21;19;19 – 00;21;20;27
Kathryn Turman
Red cross. I’ll do it.
00;21;21;00 – 00;24;21;21
Sharon Bryson
For someone else. Someone else will do it. And I think, you know, when I was, you know, having conversations with the NTSB in the early days of the program, I said one of the things that’s going to be really important is that the team, the the assistance team, is going to have to travel with the investigators. I’m going to have to know what you know right from the get go in order to do the work that I need to do. It can’t be something that will happen later or after the fact. And so getting them to understand that that work was as important as reading a recorder or kicking ten, was no easy task. And but but I think was absolutely critical. I, I, I hate to use the term that I hear. I hear this all the time. It’s good business to to get the, to get this right. But at the end of the day, thinking about those who have been impacted could be impacted, making that a priority in your emergency response plans has to be a part of your business. It can’t be something that you think about later or that you put less of a priority on. And I think when NTSB finally understood the value of having the disaster assistance team side by side with the investigators, with a mutual respect and the sharing of resources and skills, that’s when NTSB started to really get it right, and be able to do a quality investigation while doing what was needed for for the families that were impacted. And it was a it really was a culture shift within the agency. That took a lot of time and a lot of targeted, thoughtful, engagement with, you know, the investigators in that process. And I think it’s safe to say today that. But and, you know, used to kind of crack me up when I moved up the ranks at the agency, and I was the managing director, and I would, you know, give them a hard time and say, well, I’m not sure if the the disaster assistance team is available to travel with you. And like, oh my God, you might have thought I was telling them they had to walk a thousand miles. It got from where? What do we need them for? To. I really don’t want to go out there without them. And so that, I think, made a difference in terms of what what was going to happen for the family members. And so, it’s been very interesting to me to watch that shift that’s taken place.
00;24;21;23 – 00;26;06;19
Kathryn Turman
We saw that in the FBI as well. It probably took a little more time. But it took hiring really good victim specialists. And, you know, agents, like any investigators, are very proprietary, protective of their cases. They don’t want anybody messing it up. And one of the first comments I got when I went to the FBI was, we don’t need some alfalfa chewing, Birkenstock wearing social worker coming in and tell us how to do our cases. And so that was sort of interesting, but got a lot of pushback. But over time, putting good victim specialists in the field, having them work with an agent, work on a case or two, and having the agent go, oh, this was really helpful. Yeah, they really added value. This was great. They took something off my shoulders. They made sure this victim had this. And then word gets around and like you share. And one of the proudest days I had was when, you know, I had we had an agent advisory committee for our program and they basically said, you know, most of the agents wouldn’t think of going to a crime scene or going out to meet with a victim without taking a victim specialist with them. And I was like, finally, yeah, yeah, we got it. And, you know, that’s something that, you know, people have to see the value on their own. But they begin to realize that not only benefits their cases, it benefits. It creates trust not with victims and families, but with communities around those survivors and families. And, you know, I remember sharing having dinner with you and Jim Hall at some point, and they were at the caucus room or someplace. And I remember him saying to me, he said, you know, you can get a lot of things right in an investigation. But if you mess up with the families from the beginning. That’s what people are going to remember. And you’re never going to get that trust back.
00;26;06;22 – 00;26;07;22
Sharon Bryson
Right.
00;26;07;24 – 00;26;44;01
Jenn Stansberry Miller
We marked 25 years since 9/11 this year, which is a tremendous milestone for the families and everybody impacted. On that event, in other situations in which both agencies would have to coordinate and work together. Can you share what that is like and how do you both coordinate, ensuring the families and survivors needs are met when there are two prominent agencies working side by side?
00;26;44;04 – 00;31;26;00
Sharon Bryson
Yeah. So there’s, you know, built kind of built into the framework. For NTSB is. Because of. The way the law is written. This NTSB has the lead for every aviation accident without regard to cause or suspected cause. And so, it’s always been that the NTSB would take the lead. And then if there was, you know, if they began to believe that there may be a criminal element, then they would there would either be a handoff or there would be an agreement between the chairman of the NTSB and the FBI director on how to proceed forward with the investigation and and the way we did it. And I think it worked quite well. We saw this in Alaska, in the Alaska 261 crash. That, we would begin the lead. But if we had any thought at all that there was a criminal component, the bureau would join us. And honestly, today, they’re almost always somewhere nearby. If they’re not, like, right there and prominent, the goal was always to make sure that when a hand-off occurred and the rules in the in the world of NTSB and the rules on public release of information in the bureau are very different. It’s not because they don’t they don’t want to give information. They’re not able to where we have a much more open capability on a safety investigation to provide information. And so we didn’t want to mess up their investigation. They didn’t want to mess up our investigation. And the protocol, basically with the family members is to make sure that when that occurs or if a handoff has to occur one day NTSB is briefing and the next day the FBI is briefing is that that’s not a cold handoff. So if there were to be a handoff, I would conduct a briefing and I would introduce Catherine and her team. We would share briefings for maybe a short period of time, and then we would step back or vice versa. We could easily both be in a family assistance center working in a joint family support operation situation. And Alaska. 261 there was a concurrent criminal investigation going on while we were doing the safety investigation, and it was kind of quietly going on off to the side. But we were having to be careful in what we released because we didn’t want to interfere with where the bureau was heading on their investigation. A lot of people, I don’t think, even really knew that there was that concurrent investigation going on with 261 that had to do with the company and their maintenance operations and the things that were going on with regard to to maintaining the fleet. And so, so but the goal in, in working on those was always that the families wouldn’t have an abrupt change, that they’d get the same services, the same quality, the same level, and much of our processes, or patterned after one another. Anyhow, they looked very similar. And so there was really in those instances, it was always the goal to just make sure that the families didn’t, didn’t get lost in the transfer of an investigation. Which, you know, again, is not easy. One day they’re getting lots of information from the NTSB, and the next thing they’re not getting anything. And what we wanted to make sure was that they didn’t see it as the bureau being unwilling to give it. It was simply that they there, you know, there’s a whole different investigative process, and they have very different rules and very different requirements to prosecute a case. And so those things were I know we had a few meetings to talk through. How would this happen? What would it look like? When would we make those introductions? You know, you don’t want to scare people, but at the same time, you know, you need them to be aware. And so, it’s a very delicate and it has to be handled, carefully from every level of the organization, from the leadership down in an organization.
00;31;26;02 – 00;31;31;11
Kathryn Turman
Yeah. I think it helped that we had M.O.U.’s- Yeah. You got.
00;31;31;14 – 00;31;32;26
Sharon Bryson
Which we did, which helped.
00;31;32;26 – 00;31;55;20
Kathryn Turman
And I know there were times we had we had a lot more people, victim specialists, you know, so that we could send in some, you know, some force multipliers to help. And if it was a, an accident, not a criminal thing. But so I think people got used to seeing, you know, like the FBI or T-people there, you know, the jackets and then the FBI victim special. Well.
00;31;55;23 – 00;32;52;16
Sharon Bryson
You know, Kathryn mentions that they had more victim specialists. You know, when when we lost a team member in a tragic car crash not associated with our work. It it was a very, to say the least, a very difficult time for a very small group of people. And Kathryn stepped up very quickly, and they covered our own call for a week, I think, while we traveled to Ohio for the funeral and the memorial service and everything. So we didn’t have to worry about, a case coming up because they stepped right in and, and they we knew each other well enough in terms of training and working together, that they could just come in and fill in for the for the NTSB team while we were, out at the memorial service. So there were there really was, you know, a lot of shared experience that took place during that time period.
00;32;52;18 – 00;35;02;14
Kathryn Turman
It made a difference because I didn’t, you know, we dealt with a lot of different types of crime and a lot of different federal agencies, and it wasn’t always that smooth. I mean, with the NTSB, we always knew that we were we were really together and presenting a consistent message and presence to families. I had other situations, like overseas hostage cases, where families were in the middle of squabbles between agencies and agencies. Tell one agency saying, you know, if you do this, you’ll be prosecuted to a family and the FBI going, no, that doesn’t happen. So, yeah. So it was really very, reassuring and not just to us, but I think we knew that if something happened and we had to work together, that it would go smoothly. And I think when nine over 11 happened, the fact that we already kind of knew each other, Sharon was the one who alerted me that morning to what was going on. And then we had our pal Meg over at the Department of Defense. So those, those preexisting relationships seemed even with some other folks to from other federal agencies made a huge difference. Yeah. Before I left the FBI, I retired in 2020. And a few months before, before Covid hit that year, I was walking through my office and there was a small group of our younger employees sort of chatting together, and they asked if they if I would stop and answer a question. And I said, sure. And they said, is this is right after the Las Vegas Harvest Festival shooting. And they said, is this this the Las Vegas shooting, the largest mass casualty you’ve ever had to deal with the FBI to deal with? And I really had to sort of step back and kind of go, wait a minute. They were probably toddlers when nine over 11 happened during in kindergarten or something. So it’s amazing that, I, I take it for granted that more people in the field would understand what nine over 11 met and what the challenges were, and I don’t think they do.
00;35;02;17 – 00;38;50;18
Sharon Bryson
Yeah, it it was definitely an unknown for sure. And I don’t think anybody really knew, you know, I, I don’t think anybody really knew in some ways where to begin. And so what helped was the framework from the Aviation Disaster Family Assistance Act had been kind of crafted at that point. It was based on that task force report and all that hard work that came from the family members from the task force, which was invaluable. So, you know, the the, the family group sort of helped us create that framework. And that framework was kind of all we had. And so we use those basic ideas of like joint family support operations. Coordination with the priority should be at what point in time how we dispersed our resources, all of those components. We introduced the airlines to the Department of Justice, to the FBI. Ken Jenkins and Lois Danvers were the two airlines in particular. But we already knew them and had a relationship with them. And so we we helped with that and making those connections that took place. But, I anyhow believe that those, those principles that were in some ways very simple but needed to be put into a report. They were basic. In many ways basic, really gave a good foundation for how to do business. And, you know, Meg and Meg being the Pentagon, Kathryn really having all of the different sites, NTSB having that support role, right. For the two agencies, we pretty much how to call every night coordinating the three of us, just to solve whatever problems had erupted and to try to, plan, plan for what we knew was was going to be happening. I mean, it’s it’s chaotic, but it’s predictable. And there are stages or gates that occur right at this point in time. This is what families are going to be focused on them. They’re going to be focused on this. Then they’re going to be focused on that. And no matter how big or how small, you should be planning for what you’re going to do when you get to that particular point in the response a little different, you know, you had to factor in New York City and, you know, some of the, you know, nuances of New York City, who fortunately did have some experience that, the medical examiner and others up there were were people Doctor Hirsh and others were very skilled at, at knowing what to do in a, in event like that. But so I think it was unique. It was incredibly chaotic. But but there was a framework that helped keep it from reducing into complete chaos. And I know people got lost along the way and, and for that, I honestly feel terrible because I do know that that happened to a few people. But for the size of it and for how quick it was happening and for how unique the circumstances were, there was a lot of really good work that went on as well.
00;38;50;21 – 00;40;51;14
Kathryn Turman
And I think to the fact that we had this coordination, these things going on when things I mean, you can have a plans, you can have everything put in place, and there’s always going to be something that goes sideways, something that you don’t expect to come up. And, you know, having those relationships really helped because I remember one day Ken Jenkins call to say that they were they were shutting down the American Family Assistance Center at Dulles Airport. But the families, I mean, Ken knew I mean, he was aware. He was like, they need this, they need more. And so I and Heather Cartwright in my office, we were talking about it. I called Meg and told her what was going on. She talked to General Von Alstyne and the next thing you knew, he said, bring them here. They can all come to the Pentagon Family Assistance Center. We moved them to a hotel in Crystal city so they could be there, when people needed emergency travel funds and the Red cross didn’t have them yet. I was at OVC, so we sent money over to the FBI for their victim emergency fund that we’d been giving them. And we set up a little mini travel agency at a hotel nearby, and paid about $350,000 in travel money for people who weren’t eligible for the airline funds. They were they weren’t passenger families, that come from all over the world. And then when the Red cross got their travel fund up, we shut that down. So we all had call centers when call centers were starting to recognize in New York that families were unsure if they weren’t going to get remains back, how were they going to go forward with processing, you know, wills and figuring out how to manage? And that led to a conversation which then led to the City of New York, Emmys office deciding to issue presumptive death certificates. So, you know, things evolve and you just have to figure it out. And it helps when you have like minded people who know each other and who can kind of help make those most decisions.
00;40;51;17 – 00;41;46;21
Jenn Stansberry Miller
So let me follow up, because you both mentioned our colleague Ken Jenkins, which brings me to respectively, you know, building relationships ahead of time is very important. Both of you mentioned having, you know, essential listening sessions and listening to the feedback from families and survivors. But what about the relationship with the air carriers and getting to know, you know, those emergency managers ahead of time? And how important was that to the success of especially the NTSB Family Systems program? But also, I mean, Katherine, you mentioned Ken as well by name. So there I’m assuming a relationship there too. So I don’t know, Sharon, if you want to start with this.
00;41;46;23 – 00;46;11;03
Sharon Bryson
So, you know, we had several significant responses prior to 9/11 after the team was built in prior to 9/11. One of those was the EgyptAir 990 crash off the coast of Rhode Island, with 214 fatalities on board a water recovery. That took a very long time. I was in Rhode Island for about three months. On, that particular response came back. I was home for about three weeks when Alaska 261 crashed in the Pacific Ocean. And, you know, we’re we’re we’re literally out in California for a month. But what we started to get was airlines asking what went well, what didn’t go well, what would you do different? How can we better prepare? I mean, the list went on and on. And so we started we started in, so Alaska took place in January of 2000. January 31st of 2000. EgyptAir was October 31st of 99. We began what was called a Chicago meeting, and it was the carriers, all of the carriers coming together. We called it the Chicago meeting because it was held in Chicago in the middle of the country. And we talked about what worked, what didn’t work, what we would, what carriers should do differently. They would present on a on a response. And the good, the bad, the ugly with the agreement that everything would be kept within that room. And if I don’t know exactly when, but I know at a point, the, the FBI, the Justice Department came into Chicago meetings, to interact when there was a need by the carrier. So we wanted to be sure that we were building out relationships with the carriers, the carrier. There’s such a critical component. They bring so much to the table. And I say that, but I also have to say, and they have to be held to task as well. So from an NTSB standpoint, I could be their best friend or their worst enemy. And a lot of that depended on whether they were prepared or not when something happened. I would be just as easy telling a family member. No, the airline is not going to buy you a Rolex. You didn’t have a Rolex before all of this. You left your watch home. But. And they’ll replace it for you. But they’re not buying you a Rolex. As I was saying to the airline, you need to get this done. Now. This is part of your assurance. You know you’re not responding like you should be. There are consequences for that. You need to make this happen. And so, there’s such a critical component. I really feel like we built pretty respectful relationships with almost every year. Carrier, who was involved in that business. And we were happy to share those relationships with anyone. If it could benefit families and, and, you know, there are lots of circumstances around, you know, you know, a single fatality, for example, that occurs. It doesn’t necessarily involve a major air carrier, but it happened in Alaska, where it’s very difficult to move family members. And so calling them and saying, can we put these folks in contact with you? And is there any way you might be able to help them get travel from the lower 48 to, you know, to where they need to go? And so those relationships were good, solid, really. I mean, many of those people are still my friends today and have relationships. But, you know, by the same token, Catherine had relationships in the criminal justice environment that we didn’t and, would often broker those relationships for us where, you know, where it was needed, making introductions and helping us, in places that we needed some assistance. So.
00;46;11;06 – 00;46;42;18
Kathryn Turman
Sharon I think the other thing you guys did that was helpful, in particular from my perspective, was you started including us in the family assistance training that you did. We would be part of the federal resource kind of panel. And I think that was helpful because we met people. They had a better understanding of what the FBI would do if they came in or were involved in a, in a, in a aftermath. So that was a great training to start with. But it was it was helpful to be part of that.
00;46;42;21 – 00;52;32;27
Sharon Bryson
You know, it it’s really important to understand. And I know I know that maintaining programs is expensive. You know, I certainly that’s a part of my world today. I know, I know, there is an expense in maintaining training and, and standards and in those kinds of things. But at the end of the day, when a tragedy happens, if you are not in a position to assist those who have been impacted and in many cases lost everything, then you really have nothing at that point, an airline that will walk away from a family group will be out of business. They, they and you can’t have that ability to respond. It doesn’t work if you haven’t prepared for it in advance. The preparation. If you don’t hear anything else in the conversation with Catherine and I, it’s it’s knowing people and coordinating and sharing information and helping each other out. And all of that comes through training and preparedness and supporting and making that a priority within your organization. It was no easy task to pull all of that together and get that process working. And so, I think it’s fragile in that it, it has it has a expiration date. If, if people don’t continue to place a focus on an emphasis on it, where they’re going to having be having to kind of reinvent the wheel, if they, if they don’t maintain that, that readiness posture that, that is, that is there. But, you can do the best investigation you can do, get everything right. If you haven’t assisted the families, then you just might as well not come to the crash site. Because all you will hear is about how poorly people were treated and how they didn’t get information and. Right. And the the complete response to the event will be overshadowed by, people’s feelings with regard to how they were treated. So I think it’s, you know, it it, you know, may not be taught in business, in business school. But it really is how people feel that dictates, where they spend their money and how they, how they choose the organization that they’re going to do business with. So from an airline standpoint, having that relationship, I think is really important, and having that preparedness is really important. So I don’t know how you go about maintaining it on a low budget. And I know it’s not I, I know it’s not cheap to do it, but these were hard fought battles. And, and they’re proven there’s a reason that all of the work is done. It’s not a nice to have, every single piece of it, including a site visit, including a memorial. All of it is a part of, making sure that people have what they need and that they are are able to. Begin to build their life going forward, whatever the new normal is, it’s really about helping people be able to put one foot in front of the other and, decide what the world is going to be like for them as they move along. And it begins on the at the very first moment that they know their family members have been impacted in a traumatic way. And you have to you have a window of opportunity that is very narrow to build that trust relationship with a family member. And when you lose that, you I rarely seen it get better. And I mean, I used to say, you know, to our investigators who would engage with a family member before they refer them to, to me or to us. And I would say, look, can you please just send them to me before you make them angry? Like, I’m happy to, to help you, but, you know, now you’ve engaged with them and they’re really mad with you. And so now you’re going to send them over here to me. And investigators were, you know, our investigators would oftentimes do that on, like, just send them to the people who have, you know, the skills to be able to help them in the first place. So, you know, I don’t know how much more you can encourage, organizations to be in a preparedness posture, but this is the one thing that they can’t if they don’t get it right, they don’t get a do over. This is it. They don’t get to say, I’ll do it better next time, because this is this is going to be a big day of judgment with regard to their ability to assist those people that have been impacted.
00;52;33;00 – 00;53;16;11
Jenn Stansberry Miller
Thank you, Sharon and Kathryn. In part two, we’ll continue our conversations about information families can trust, the care of remains and personal belongings, and the importance of site visits and memorials will also explore support across generations and what future leaders need to know to carry forward. If your organization needs help with family systems, planning, training or response, visit www.Empatha.com. To hear more episodes of OnTopic with Empathia, visit our website or subscribe wherever you listen to podcast. I’m Jenn Stansberry Miller. Thank you for listening.




